I love what began as a poem written in Old Irish somewhere between the sixth and eleventh century. It is now found in many church hymnals and is especially popular in the UK.
What I think is important to us English speakers is that it was translated in 1905 and then placed into verse in 1912.
So what’s my point so far?
Simply that, like many things in life, there is something precious about how truth and beauty distill over the rocky roads of time. Certainly there are songs and works of art I don’t understand — and a big clue that I am missing something important is when others I respect consider something worth my time, like a famous Latin choral mass composed by Bach or Haydn, for example.
Of course there are some pop songs that grab me, but usually these also only hold my interest momentarily.
If I had to explain why this is — that some works of art endure and others do not, I would say it has to do with how layered they are. And by layered I mean on how many levels they are able to activate certain parts of my brain that throw me into memories and deep unsettled thoughts. Themes like life, death, goodness, and evil hold my interest longer compered with wishing they were all California girls, for example. And this isn’t to say that we can’t learn a lot by studying pop culture and popular songs of the day — but what I think is most helpful when trying to understand the times we are living in is to see them in the context of a longer and often richer historical context.
For example, think about this. Back in the time of our Founding Fathers Beethoven lived in Vienna. He was a prolific composer. And yet those who lived when he did, for the most part never heard his music, and if they did, they heard it performed, which meant that those who heard pieces played more than once were usually other musicians, those doing the playing.
Now how many times have you listened to any of your favorite songs? Might this explain the appetite for audiences back then to listen to longer pieces? They would have wanted to sit and bask in the sound, knowing they might never hear it again. And might it also help explain why sections in long pieces are often repeated two and three times?
And what about those boring hymns at church? What if this was the only music people would hear in a week? And isn’t it true that well crafted lyrics placed within well composed music aids in retention of important information and ideas?
With all this in mind (pre-layered into your thoughts) read, as if for the first time, Be Thou My Vision. Don’t rush. Take time to draw out its meaning for you today.
Be Thou My Vision
English version by Eleanor Hull (1912)
Great insight Ben! Also, Be Thou My Vision is a long time favorite memorized in my heart & mind. I can’t hear or sing it without tears coming to my eyes. Now I need to add that third verse.
I have always loved this great hymn! I have never heard that third verse "Be Thou my battle Sheild". I like it very much but it's not in our hymnal. I wish it was it was. This was a beautiful version.